• Registered: 2019-01-15
  • Posts: 454

I'm trying to dump one of the missing XBOX games ("Scarface") that DIC seems to have an issue with right at the start.
I have two copies of the game and both are doing the same thing.

LBA[1913770, 0x1d33aa]: [F:ReadXBOXDirectoryRecord][L:1180]
    Opcode: 0xa8
    ScsiStatus: 0x02 = CHECK_CONDITION
    SenseData Key-Asc-Ascq: 03-02-00 = MEDIUM_ERROR - NO SEEK COMPLETE

Here are the other logs : https://mega.nz/file/pA4E0aSa#QlvW1odUt … pZRyaoaT8o

I tried with XBC and Freecell, which are dumping it fine...up to a certain point.

Any idea of what could be happening ? smile

3,152 Reply by sarami

  • Registered: 2011-02-20
  • Posts: 1,745

KailoKyra wrote:

I'm trying to dump one of the missing XBOX games ("Scarface") that DIC seems to have an issue with right at the start.

Same problem. http://forum.redump.org/post/97197/#p97197

Scarface is http://redump.org/disc/60487/ ? or http://redump.org/disc/36869/ ?
Tell me Amazon or eBay link, plz.

DiscImageCreator, UmdImageCreator, Conv2multiBin, bin2wav, PS3Auth (needs login), recompressTo7z_20150109.bat

sarami's Website

3,153 Reply by KailoKyra (edited by KailoKyra 2021-12-08 01:08:20)

  • Registered: 2019-01-15
  • Posts: 454

Probably the later, but maybe it's different than the regular english/european release.
It's the one listed in the PAL missing list (with the french cover which has a "Contenu Explicite" warning at the top left)

Here's an ebay listing, it's a pretty uncommon one: https://www.ebay.fr/itm/203694810733?ha … SwzNJhjYSA
Though not sure if it isn't just a stock picture, might be a good idea to ask the seller first.

Otherwise, as I have two copies, I can always send one your way.

  • Registered: 2015-06-08
  • Posts: 367

Tried to dump PS2 cheat discs with big data protection, always getting different hashes with newest versions of DIC, DICUI and DIC_test. Maybe you can take a look at it, logs are here:

https://mega.nz/file/1ZF1SKTK#MoD4ipZzA … 1wO-SIlW3E
https://mega.nz/file/ERcBHITT#OrgGXqGNq … pQwf4ISZIs

3,155 Reply by sarami (edited by sarami 2021-12-14 03:53:58)

  • Registered: 2011-02-20
  • Posts: 1,745

retaliator wrote:

Tried to dump PS2 cheat discs with big data protection, always getting different hashes with newest versions of DIC, DICUI and DIC_test.

statiomaster_032002_20210701T212154.txt --> It's old version. Typically, the bug report of the old version is meaningless.

And it's a known issue. http://forum.redump.org/post/96246/#p96246 http://forum.redump.org/post/96445/#p96445
Please check which bytes of the img of the latest DIC are different using fc command by the command prompt.

fc /b statiomaster_022002.img statiomaster_032002.img
DiscImageCreator, UmdImageCreator, Conv2multiBin, bin2wav, PS3Auth (needs login), recompressTo7z_20150109.bat

sarami's Website

  • Registered: 2015-06-08
  • Posts: 367

sarami wrote:
retaliator wrote:

Tried to dump PS2 cheat discs with big data protection, always getting different hashes with newest versions of DIC, DICUI and DIC_test.

statiomaster_032002_20210701T212154.txt --> It's old version. Typically, the bug report of the old version is meaningless.

Please check which bytes of the img of the latest DIC are different using fc command by the command prompt.

fc /b statiomaster_022002.img statiomaster_032002.img

As I wrote I used various versions, also the newest from github with same result: hashes not matching. I didn't knew that the logs from old versions are meaningless, uploaded any I had left on HDD. I'll dump them again and put those new logs up, also do that compare you mentioned.

3,157 Reply by sarami

  • Registered: 2011-02-20
  • Posts: 1,745

I've been tired to say "Please use the latest version" every time, especially MPF users.
I recommend github issue from now on when the bug is reported.
If it is reported in this forum, see the bug_report.md.

DiscImageCreator, UmdImageCreator, Conv2multiBin, bin2wav, PS3Auth (needs login), recompressTo7z_20150109.bat

sarami's Website

3,158 Reply by user7 (edited by user7 2021-12-16 03:06:59)

  • user7
  • Moderator
  • Offline
  • Registered: 2009-03-14
  • Posts: 2,621

user7 wrote:
sarami wrote:

@user7
Tell me the ebay or amazon or discogs link of "HighlightsVCD", please.

"Philips Media Presents: CD-i Games: Highlights-Previews-Gameclips" not to be confused with a similarly titled one for movies.

Three listings on ebay right now and all UK shipping only hmm

sarami if you're still looking for this VCD http://redump.org/disc/74810/ which gives wonky errors, there's one in this pack that ships worldwide: https://www.ebay.nl/itm/265429499035

I think this could be a key to saving a lot of VCDs with dumping errors - it seems this DIC dumping bug effects many VCDs in general (maybe 10-15% from my experience).

See also discussion here: http://forum.redump.org/post/91000/#p91000

All my posts and submission data are released into Public Domain / CC0.
  • Registered: 2019-01-15
  • Posts: 454

KailoKyra wrote:

I'm trying to dump one of the missing XBOX games ("Scarface") that DIC seems to have an issue with right at the start.
I have two copies of the game and both are doing the same thing.

LBA[1913770, 0x1d33aa]: [F:ReadXBOXDirectoryRecord][L:1180]
    Opcode: 0xa8
    ScsiStatus: 0x02 = CHECK_CONDITION
    SenseData Key-Asc-Ascq: 03-02-00 = MEDIUM_ERROR - NO SEEK COMPLETE

Follow up on that : I managed to grab another copy, same ringcode and all... and this time it worked without issues.
So likely something bad going on with the discs themselves even if they don't look visually bad.

3,160 Reply by sarami

  • Registered: 2011-02-20
  • Posts: 1,745

user7 wrote:

sarami if you're still looking for this VCD http://redump.org/disc/74810/ which gives wonky errors, there's one in this pack that ships worldwide: https://www.ebay.nl/itm/265429499035

Ordered it.

KailoKyra wrote:

I managed to grab another copy, same ringcode and all... and this time it worked without issues.
So likely something bad going on with the discs themselves even if they don't look visually bad.

It's weird... Do you upload these logs? Generally, "MEDIUM_ERROR - NO SEEK COMPLETE" is a drive problem.

DiscImageCreator, UmdImageCreator, Conv2multiBin, bin2wav, PS3Auth (needs login), recompressTo7z_20150109.bat

sarami's Website

3,161 Reply by Jackal (edited by Jackal 2021-12-26 10:16:39)

  • Jackal
  • Moderator (Retired)
  • Offline
  • Registered: 2006-12-23
  • Posts: 4,132

http://redump.org/disc/74600/

Why is it counting 150 sectors as part of write offset? Is it a bug?

Logs: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1lbh0vA … sp=sharing

And also: http://redump.org/disc/77974/

3,162 Reply by Jackal (edited by Jackal 2021-12-26 11:00:25)

  • Jackal
  • Moderator (Retired)
  • Offline
  • Registered: 2006-12-23
  • Posts: 4,132

Also my input for automatic offset correction:

There should be a limit on the maximum amount of non-zero samples that are corrected.
Looking at some of the large offsets that are dumped:
-9392 http://redump.org/disc/78870/
(next one is -4707)
+6722 http://redump.org/disc/1838/
(and several +5292)

It seems that maybe -10.000 to +10.000 samples seems like a logical range.

Here is my proposed method for automatic offset detection for Audio CD's:

Step 1: Determine the amount of non-zero data in the lead-out:
- If there are >10.000 samples of non-zero data in the lead-out, then this is a strange disc that violates Red Book standards. Offset correction is skipped and the disc is dumped with 0 offset?
- If there are ≤10.000 samples of non-zero data in the lead-out, then look if there's at least an equal amount of zero samples at the start of Track01. If this is the case, then proceed to use this as the custom offset correction (shift data to the left).
- If there are less zero samples at the start of Track01 than non-zero samples in the lead-out, then this is a strange disc that violates Red Book standards. Offset correction is skipped and the disc is dumped with 0 offset?
Step 2: This step should only be performed if no non-zero data was found in the lead-out. Determine the amount of non-zero data in the Track01 pregap, counting backwards from sector -1.
- If no non-zero data is found in the Track01 pregap, then no offset correction is required and the disc is dumped with 0 offset.
- If there are >10.000 samples of non-zero data in the pregap, then this is a strange disc that violates Red Book standards. Offset correction is skipped and the disc is dumped with 0 offset?
- If there are ≤10.000 samples of non-zero data in the pregap, then look if there's at least an equal amount of zero samples at the end of the last track. If this is the case, then proceed to use this as the custom offset correction (shift data to the right). If there are less zero samples at the end of the last track than non-zero samples in the Track01 pregap, then again this is a strange disc and 0 offset should be used?

The staff will discuss (and perhaps refine) this proposed solution and then we will inform you.

3,163 Reply by scsi_wuzzy (edited by scsi_wuzzy 2021-12-26 16:27:16)

  • Registered: 2015-02-24
  • Posts: 101

KailoKyra wrote:

Follow up on that : I managed to grab another copy, same ringcode and all... and this time it worked without issues.
So likely something bad going on with the discs themselves even if they don't look visually bad.

Out of curiosity, try scanning the bad disc in a flatbed scanner. My near perfect copy of JSRF would not read correctly in either my Xbox 360 or my Kreon drive, and I couldn't make sense of it. When I scanned the disc on the flatbed, though, there were tons of tiny little black spots that I couldn't easily see with the naked eye.

I think maybe one of the Xbox disc manufacturers had an issue with some batches of discs, and they're oxidizing or otherwise rotting away. I've seen reports of other perfectly good looking JSRF discs having the same problem, and I'm sure there are others besides the JSRF discs.

I'm pretty sure my JSRF disc did not have this problem when I purchased it new years ago. I vaguely remember having a modded Xbox extract the disc shortly after purchase, so it was readable at that time, and it's been in the case ever since. I didn't try dumping it proper until I finally got a Kreon drive this year, though I noticed last year that my 360 wouldn't play the disc.

3,164 Reply by sarami

  • Registered: 2011-02-20
  • Posts: 1,745

Jackal wrote:

Why is it counting 150 sectors as part of write offset? Is it a bug?

As it is written in the comment of http://redump.org/disc/77974/ , these discs start AMSF 00:00:00, not 00:02:00. Due to this problem, there is not the sync in the last 150 data sectors. EccEdc judges it as error.

Jackal wrote:

Here is my proposed method for automatic offset detection for Audio CD's:

I translate the src I already coded to English. Thanks to Intothisworld, perhaps it's almost coded except -10.000 to +10.000 samples you say.
I hope to test the latest version of the https://github.com/saramibreak/DiscImag … /issues/95 to more people.

1. Check the non-zero byte position from last - 75 to last + 75.
2. Check the non-zero byte position from LBA 0 - 75 to LBA 0 + 75.
3-1. If the difference of the last non-zero byte position and 1st non-zero byte position are bigger than 0 sample and smaller than 588 samples...
3-1-1. If the last non-zero byte position is equal to the 1st non-zero byte position, Set the custom offset.
3-1-2. If the last non-zero byte position is bigger than the 1st non-zero byte position, It can't set the custom offset.
3-1-3. If the last non-zero byte position is smaller than the 1st non-zero byte position.
3-1-3-1. If the 1st non-zero byte position is smaller than the combined offset, Set the custom offset.
3-1-3-2. If not 3-1-3-1, it's no need to fix the combined offset.
3-2. If the difference of the last non-zero byte position and 1st non-zero byte position are bigger than 588 samples... (last < 1st)
3-2-1. If the last non-zero byte exists in the last sector or lead-out and the 1st non-zero byte exists in the LBA 0 or backward.
3-2-1-1. If the last non-zero byte position exists in the last sector and its position is smaller than the combined offset, it's no need to fix the combined offset.
3-2-1-2. If not 3-2-1-1, set the custom offset.
3-2-2. If the last non-zero byte exists in the forward than the last sector and the 1st non-zero byte exists in the LBA 0 or backward.
3-2-2-1. If the 1st non-zero byte exists in the LBA 0 and the 1st non-zero byte position is smaller than the combined offset, Set the custom offset.
3-2-2-2. If not 3-2-2-1, it's no need to fix the combined offset.
3-2-3. If the last non-zero byte exists in the forward than the last sector and the 1st non-zero byte exists in the pregap sector, Set the custom offset.
3-3. If the difference of the last non-zero byte position and 1st non-zero byte position are bigger than 588 samples... (1st < last)
3-3-1. If the 1st non-zero byte exists in the LBA 0 or backward and the last non-zero byte exists in the last sector or lead-out, it can't set the custom offset.
3-3-2. If the 1st non-zero byte exists in the pregap and the last non-zero byte exists in the last sector or lead-out, it can't set the custom offset.
3-3-3. If the last non-zero byte exists in the last sector and the last non-zero byte position is smaller than the combined offset, it's no need to fix the combined offset.
3-3-4. if not 3-3-3, set the custom offset.
3-3-5. If the 1st non-zero byte exists in the pregap and the last non-zero byte exists in the forward than the last sector, it can't set the custom offset.
3-3-6. If not 3-3-5, it's no need to fix the combined offset.
DiscImageCreator, UmdImageCreator, Conv2multiBin, bin2wav, PS3Auth (needs login), recompressTo7z_20150109.bat

sarami's Website

3,165 Reply by gmipf (edited by gmipf 2021-12-27 16:30:22)

  • Registered: 2019-04-04
  • Posts: 1,497

@sarami: I wanted to know how you did dumped that disc: http://redump.org/disc/45814/

Did you just used the /sf command for Bitpool?

  • Registered: 2014-10-06
  • Posts: 704

In the past Bitpool discs were 'fixed' with custom tool (replacing with 0x55). But recently it's was considered imperfect and all Bitpool discs have to be redumped without any kind of 'fixes'.

3,167 Reply by gmipf

  • Registered: 2019-04-04
  • Posts: 1,497

And how does the dump work?

3,168 Reply by sarami

  • Registered: 2011-02-20
  • Posts: 1,745

gmipf wrote:

@sarami: I wanted to know how you did dumped that disc: http://redump.org/disc/45814/

Did you just used the /sf command for Bitpool?

Redumped it. https://www.mediafire.com/file/7r5xtssh … og.7z/file

DiscImageCreator, UmdImageCreator, Conv2multiBin, bin2wav, PS3Auth (needs login), recompressTo7z_20150109.bat

sarami's Website

3,169 Reply by gmipf

  • Registered: 2019-04-04
  • Posts: 1,497

sarami wrote:
gmipf wrote:

@sarami: I wanted to know how you did dumped that disc: http://redump.org/disc/45814/

Did you just used the /sf command for Bitpool?

Redumped it. https://www.mediafire.com/file/7r5xtssh … og.7z/file

Here is my log: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1wj281R … sp=sharing

Something weird is going on on my side. In your logs it seems the protected sectors are handled correctly but on my side it tries to reread some of the sectors despite being already detected as protected.

Here the console output too:

gmipf@wks01:/media/Daten/DiscImageCreator_linux$ sudo ./DiscImageCreator_linux.out cd /dev/sr2 dumps/pc_cultures/dump.bin 0 /c2 1 /sf
AppVersion
        x64, AnsiBuild, 20211101T132455
/c2 val2 was omitted. set [0]
/sf val was omitted. set [60]
CurrentDirectory
        /media/Daten/DiscImageCreator_linux
WorkingPath
         Argument: dumps/pc_cultures/dump.bin
         FullPath: /media/Daten/DiscImageCreator_linux/dumps/pc_cultures/dump.bin
            Drive: /
        Directory: media/Daten/DiscImageCreator_linux/dumps/pc_cultures/
         Filename: dump
        Extension: .bin
StartTime: 2021-12-28T15:12:35+0100
          Block Size: 4096
       Flagment Size: 4096
       All Block Num: 124606720
      Free Block Num: 81407902
 Available Block Num: 81248230
          I Node Num: 0
     Free I Node Num: 0
Available I Node Num: 0
      File System ID: 3301985167766541070
          Mount Flag: 4096
 Max Filename Length: 255
CurrentDriveSize
        Total: 510389125120 bytes
         Used: 332792750080 bytes
        --------------------------
        Space: 177596375040 bytes
         => There is enough the disk space for dumping
This drive supports [OpCode: 0xd8, SubCode: 0]
This drive supports [OpCode: 0xd8, SubCode: 1]
This drive supports [OpCode: 0xd8, SubCode: 2]
This drive supports [OpCode: 0xd8, SubCode: 8]
Checking reading lead-out -> OK
Checking SubQ adr (Track) 16/16
Checking SubRtoW (Track) 16/16
Checking Pregap sync, msf, mode (LBA)  -2448
Reading DirectoryRecord    4/   4

Detected a protected file [CD.IDX]. LBA 32 to 97654
Set OpCode: 0xd8, SubCode: 8(Raw)
Checking SubQ ctl (Track) 16/16
Creating .scm (LBA)  85473/34 LBA[085499, 0x14dfb] Detected C2 error 566 bit
 LBA[085500, 0x14dfc] Detected C2 error 982 bit
 LBA[085501, 0x14dfd] Detected C2 error 1901 bit
 LBA[085502, 0x14dfe] Detected C2 error 1193 bit
Creating .scm (LBA)  85503/346775 LBA[085511, 0x14e07] Detected C2 error 1146 bit
 LBA[085513, 0x14e09] Detected C2 error 1194 bit
 LBA[085515, 0x14e0b] Detected C2 error 1150 bit
 LBA[085517, 0x14e0d] Detected C2 error 1168 bit
 LBA[085519, 0x14e0f] Detected C2 error 1203 bit
 LBA[085521, 0x14e11] Detected C2 error 1179 bit
 LBA[085523, 0x14e13] Detected C2 error 1156 bit
 LBA[085525, 0x14e15] Detected C2 error 1213 bit
 LBA[085527, 0x14e17] Detected C2 error 1189 bit
 LBA[085529, 0x14e19] Detected C2 error 1170 bit
 LBA[085531, 0x14e1b] Detected C2 error 1198 bit
 LBA[085533, 0x14e1d] Detected C2 error 1164 bit
Cre LBA[085535, 0x14e1f] Detected C2 error 1181 bit
 LBA[085537, 0x14e21] Detected C2 error 610 bit
 LBA[085538, 0x14e22] Detected C2 error 1553 bit
 LBA[085539, 0x14e23] Detected C2 error 744 bit
 LBA[085540, 0x14e24] Detected C2 error 688 bit
 LBA[085541, 0x14e25] Detected C2 error 1004 bit
 LBA[085542, 0x14e26] Detected C2 error 1835 bit
 LBA[085543, 0x14e27] Detected C2 error 1678 bit
 LBA[085544, 0x14e28] Detected C2 error 450 bit
 LBA[085545, 0x14e29] Detected C2 error 905 bit
 LBA[085546, 0x14e2a] Detected C2 error 1274 bit
 LBA[085547, 0x14e2b] Detected C2 error 2080 bit
 LBA[085548, 0x14e2c] Detected C2 error 632 bit
 LBA[085549, 0x14e2d] Detected C2 error 772 bit
 LBA[085550, 0x14e2e] Detected C2 error 1082 bit
 LBA[085551, 0x14e2f] Detected C2 error 1885 bit
 LBA[085552, 0x14e30] Detected C2 error 1595 bit
 LBA[085553, 0x14e31] Detected C2 error 455 bit
 LBA[085554, 0x14e32] Detected C2 error 927 bit
 LBA[085555, 0x14e33] Detected C2 error 1356 bit
 LBA[085556, 0x14e34] Detected C2 error 2072 bit
 LBA[085557, 0x14e35] Detected C2 error 568 bit
 LBA[085558, 0x14e36] Detected C2 error 777 bit
 LBA[085559, 0x14e37] Detected C2 error 1077 bit
 LBA[085560, 0x14e38] Detected C2 error 1882 bit
 LBA[085561, 0x14e39] Detected C2 error 1408 bit
 LBA[085562, 0x14e3a] Detected C2 error 422 bit
 LBA[085563, 0x14e3b] Detected C2 error 907 bit
 LBA[085564, 0x14e3c] Detected C2 error 1343 bit
Creatin LBA[085565, 0x14e3d] Detected C2 error 2011 bit
 LBA[085566, 0x14e3e] Detected C2 error 492 bit
 LBA[085567, 0x14e3f] Detected C2 error 738 bit
 LBA[085568, 0x14e40] Detected C2 error 1432 bit
 LBA[085569, 0x14e41] Detected C2 error 1543 bit
 LBA[085570, 0x14e42] Detected C2 error 2005 bit
 LBA[085571, 0x14e43] Detected C2 error 505 bit
 LBA[085572, 0x14e44] Detected C2 error 887 bit
 LBA[085573, 0x14e45] Detected C2 error 1172 bit
 LBA[085574, 0x14e46] Detected C2 error 1958 bit
 LBA[085575, 0x14e47] Detected C2 error 1145 bit
 LBA[085576, 0x14e48] Detected C2 error 486 bit
 LBA[085577, 0x14e49] Detected C2 error 959 bit
 LBA[085578, 0x14e4a] Detected C2 error 1504 bit
 LBA[085579, 0x14e4b] Detected C2 error 1959 bit
 LBA[085580, 0x14e4c] Detected C2 error 468 bit
 LBA[085581, 0x14e4d] Detected C2 error 751 bit
 LBA[085582, 0x14e4e] Detected C2 error 1447 bit
 LBA[085583, 0x14e4f] Detected C2 error 1632 bit
 LBA[085584, 0x14e50] Detected C2 error 1894 bit
 LBA[085585, 0x14e51] Detected C2 error 447 bit
 LBA[085586, 0x14e52] Detected C2 error 778 bit
 LBA[085587, 0x14e53] Detected C2 error 1529 bit
 LBA[085588, 0x14e54] Detected C2 error 1754 bit
 LBA[085589, 0x14e55] Detected C2 error 1646 bit
 LBA[085590, 0x14e56] Detected C2 error 403 bit
 LBA[085591, 0x14e57] Detected C2 error 873 bit
 LBA[085592, 0x14e58] Detected C2 error 1319 bit
 LBA[085593, 0x14e59] Detected C2 error 2056 bit
 LBA[085594, 0x14e5a] Detected C2 error 598 bit
Creating .s LBA[085595, 0x14e5b] Detected C2 error 818 bit
 LBA[085596, 0x14e5c] Detected C2 error 1489 bit
 LBA[085597, 0x14e5d] Detected C2 error 1672 bit
 LBA[085598, 0x14e5e] Detected C2 error 2081 bit
 LBA[085599, 0x14e5f] Detected C2 error 594 bit
 LBA[085600, 0x14e60] Detected C2 error 849 bit
 LBA[085601, 0x14e61] Detected C2 error 1510 bit
 LBA[085602, 0x14e62] Detected C2 error 1705 bit
 LBA[085603, 0x14e63] Detected C2 error 1979 bit
 LBA[085604, 0x14e64] Detected C2 error 502 bit
 LBA[085605, 0x14e65] Detected C2 error 806 bit
 LBA[085606, 0x14e66] Detected C2 error 1183 bit
 LBA[085607, 0x14e67] Detected C2 error 1973 bit
 LBA[085608, 0x14e68] Detected C2 error 1311 bit
 LBA[085609, 0x14e69] Detected C2 error 492 bit
 LBA[085610, 0x14e6a] Detected C2 error 946 bit
 LBA[085611, 0x14e6b] Detected C2 error 1565 bit
 LBA[085612, 0x14e6c] Detected C2 error 1914 bit
 LBA[085613, 0x14e6d] Detected C2 error 493 bit
 LBA[085614, 0x14e6e] Detected C2 error 799 bit
 LBA[085615, 0x14e6f] Detected C2 error 1443 bit
 LBA[085616, 0x14e70] Detected C2 error 1499 bit
 LBA[085617, 0x14e71] Detected C2 error 2073 bit
 LBA[085618, 0x14e72] Detected C2 error 596 bit
 LBA[085619, 0x14e73] Detected C2 error 815 bit
 LBA[085620, 0x14e74] Detected C2 error 1128 bit
 LBA[085621, 0x14e75] Detected C2 error 1914 bit
 LBA[085622, 0x14e76] Detected C2 error 1241 bit
 LBA[085623, 0x14e77] Detected C2 error 409 bit
 LBA[085624, 0x14e78] Detected C2 error 874 bit
Creating .scm ( LBA[085625, 0x14e79] Detected C2 error 1439 bit
 LBA[085626, 0x14e7a] Detected C2 error 2020 bit
 LBA[085627, 0x14e7b] Detected C2 error 508 bit
 LBA[085628, 0x14e7c] Detected C2 error 762 bit
 LBA[085629, 0x14e7d] Detected C2 error 1353 bit
 LBA[085630, 0x14e7e] Detected C2 error 2058 bit
 LBA[085631, 0x14e7f] Detected C2 error 1216 bit
 LBA[085632, 0x14e80] Detected C2 error 468 bit
 LBA[085633, 0x14e81] Detected C2 error 936 bit
 LBA[085634, 0x14e82] Detected C2 error 1500 bit
 LBA[085635, 0x14e83] Detected C2 error 2074 bit
 LBA[085636, 0x14e84] Detected C2 error 585 bit
 LBA[085637, 0x14e85] Detected C2 error 786 bit
 LBA[085638, 0x14e86] Detected C2 error 1455 bit
 LBA[085639, 0x14e87] Detected C2 error 1618 bit
 LBA[085640, 0x14e88] Detected C2 error 1942 bit
 LBA[085641, 0x14e89] Detected C2 error 485 bit
 LBA[085642, 0x14e8a] Detected C2 error 867 bit
 LBA[085643, 0x14e8b] Detected C2 error 1770 bit
 LBA[085644, 0x14e8c] Detected C2 error 1725 bit
 LBA[085645, 0x14e8d] Detected C2 error 435 bit
 LBA[085646, 0x14e8e] Detected C2 error 861 bit
 LBA[085647, 0x14e8f] Detected C2 error 1242 bit
 LBA[085648, 0x14e90] Detected C2 error 2023 bit
 LBA[085649, 0x14e91] Detected C2 error 661 bit
 LBA[085650, 0x14e92] Detected C2 error 662 bit
 LBA[085651, 0x14e93] Detected C2 error 1348 bit
 LBA[085652, 0x14e94] Detected C2 error 1615 bit
 LBA[085653, 0x14e95] Detected C2 error 2068 bit
 LBA[085654, 0x14e96] Detected C2 error 613 bit
Creating .scm (LBA) LBA[085655, 0x14e97] Detected C2 error 679 bit
 LBA[085656, 0x14e98] Detected C2 error 1046 bit
 LBA[085657, 0x14e99] Detected C2 error 1875 bit
 LBA[085658, 0x14e9a] Detected C2 error 1595 bit
 LBA[085659, 0x14e9b] Detected C2 error 444 bit
 LBA[085660, 0x14e9c] Detected C2 error 1026 bit
 LBA[085661, 0x14e9d] Detected C2 error 1394 bit
 LBA[085662, 0x14e9e] Detected C2 error 2129 bit
 LBA[085663, 0x14e9f] Detected C2 error 767 bit
 LBA[085664, 0x14ea0] Detected C2 error 693 bit
 LBA[085665, 0x14ea1] Detected C2 error 1393 bit
 LBA[085666, 0x14ea2] Detected C2 error 1614 bit
 LBA[085667, 0x14ea3] Detected C2 error 2043 bit
 LBA[085668, 0x14ea4] Detected C2 error 526 bit
 LBA[085669, 0x14ea5] Detected C2 error 908 bit
 LBA[085670, 0x14ea6] Detected C2 error 1112 bit
 LBA[085671, 0x14ea7] Detected C2 error 1874 bit
 LBA[085672, 0x14ea8] Detected C2 error 1384 bit
 LBA[085673, 0x14ea9] Detected C2 error 451 bit
 LBA[085674, 0x14eaa] Detected C2 error 951 bit
 LBA[085675, 0x14eab] Detected C2 error 1374 bit
 LBA[085676, 0x14eac] Detected C2 error 2039 bit
 LBA[085677, 0x14ead] Detected C2 error 822 bit
 LBA[085678, 0x14eae] Detected C2 error 1300 bit
 LBA[085679, 0x14eaf] Detected C2 error 2051 bit
 LBA[085680, 0x14eb0] Detected C2 error 747 bit
 LBA[085681, 0x14eb1] Detected C2 error 587 bit
 LBA[085682, 0x14eb2] Detected C2 error 962 bit
 LBA[085683, 0x14eb3] Detected C2 error 1764 bit
 LBA[085684, 0x14eb4] Detected C2 error 1755 bit
Creating .scm (LBA)  85 LBA[085685, 0x14eb5] Detected C2 error 430 bit
 LBA[085686, 0x14eb6] Detected C2 error 880 bit
 LBA[085687, 0x14eb7] Detected C2 error 1300 bit
 LBA[085688, 0x14eb8] Detected C2 error 2074 bit
 LBA[085689, 0x14eb9] Detected C2 error 819 bit
 LBA[085690, 0x14eba] Detected C2 error 690 bit
 LBA[085691, 0x14ebb] Detected C2 error 1003 bit
 LBA[085692, 0x14ebc] Detected C2 error 1763 bit
 LBA[085693, 0x14ebd] Detected C2 error 1798 bit
 LBA[085694, 0x14ebe] Detected C2 error 500 bit
 LBA[085695, 0x14ebf] Detected C2 error 987 bit
 LBA[085696, 0x14ec0] Detected C2 error 1557 bit
 LBA[085697, 0x14ec1] Detected C2 error 1774 bit
 LBA[085698, 0x14ec2] Detected C2 error 1710 bit
 LBA[085699, 0x14ec3] Detected C2 error 431 bit
 LBA[085700, 0x14ec4] Detected C2 error 848 bit
 LBA[085701, 0x14ec5] Detected C2 error 1251 bit
 LBA[085702, 0x14ec6] Detected C2 error 2051 bit
 LBA[085703, 0x14ec7] Detected C2 error 676 bit
Creating .scm (LBA) 346775/346775
Need to reread sector:  85703 rereading times:    1/   1
Done. See _c2Error.txt
Copying .scm to .img
Descrambling data sector of img:  98103/ 98103
Exec /media/Daten/DiscImageCreator_linux/./EccEdc_linux.out check "/media/Daten/DiscImageCreator_linux/dumps/pc_cultures/dump.img"
FILE: /media/Daten/DiscImageCreator_linux/dumps/pc_cultures/dump.img
Checking sectors: 346774/346774
[ERROR] Number of sector(s) where bad MSF: 1216
[ERROR] Number of sector(s) where user data doesn't match the expected ECC/EDC: 18
[ERROR] Number of sector(s) where sync(0x00 - 0x0c) is invalid: 256
[ERROR] Number of sector(s) where sync(0x00 - 0x0c) is zero: 18
Total errors: 1508
Total warnings: 0
Creating cue and ccd (Track) 16/16
Creating bin (Track) 16/16
Hashing: dump.scm
Hashing: dump.img
Hashing: dump (Track 01).bin
Hashing: dump (Track 02).bin
Hashing: dump (Track 03).bin
Hashing: dump (Track 04).bin
Hashing: dump (Track 05).bin
Hashing: dump (Track 06).bin
Hashing: dump (Track 07).bin
Hashing: dump (Track 08).bin
Hashing: dump (Track 09).bin
Hashing: dump (Track 10).bin
Hashing: dump (Track 11).bin
Hashing: dump (Track 12).bin
Hashing: dump (Track 13).bin
Hashing: dump (Track 14).bin
Hashing: dump (Track 15).bin
Hashing: dump (Track 16).bin
EndTime: 2021-12-28T15:42:15+0100
gmipf@wks01:/media/Daten/DiscImageCreator_linux$ sudo chown -R gmipf:gmipf dumps/
[sudo] password for gmipf: 
gmipf@wks01:/media/Daten/DiscImageCreator_linux$

3,170 Reply by sarami

  • Registered: 2011-02-20
  • Posts: 1,745

gmipf wrote:

Something weird is going on on my side. In your logs it seems the protected sectors are handled correctly but on my side it tries to reread some of the sectors despite being already detected as protected.

My disc doesn't have an intentional C2 error. It seems several versions(?) exist in this protection.

DiscImageCreator, UmdImageCreator, Conv2multiBin, bin2wav, PS3Auth (needs login), recompressTo7z_20150109.bat

sarami's Website

3,171 Reply by gmipf (edited by gmipf 2021-12-29 15:38:50)

  • Registered: 2019-04-04
  • Posts: 1,497

I have installed the game without any errors. I would assume the disc is in working order.

EDIT: What is the speed of 0 meaning? Didn't knew that value is possible.

3,172 Reply by user7

  • user7
  • Moderator
  • Offline
  • Registered: 2009-03-14
  • Posts: 2,621

sarami, here's another disc you might want to snag for study: https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/133917616260

It seems like we've run into anomalies / difference in hashes time and time again with this disc over the past couple years.

example: http://forum.redump.org/topic/41618/cdi … d-windows/

All my posts and submission data are released into Public Domain / CC0.

3,173 Reply by sarami

  • Registered: 2011-02-20
  • Posts: 1,745

user7 wrote:

here's another disc you might want to snag for study

I have already another one.
http://forum.redump.org/post/84421/#p84421
I redumped it, but it generated the same hash.

DiscImageCreator, UmdImageCreator, Conv2multiBin, bin2wav, PS3Auth (needs login), recompressTo7z_20150109.bat

sarami's Website

3,174 Reply by gmipf (edited by gmipf 2022-01-04 22:18:10)

  • Registered: 2019-04-04
  • Posts: 1,497

user7 wrote:

sarami, here's another disc you might want to snag for study: https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/133917616260

It seems like we've run into anomalies / difference in hashes time and time again with this disc over the past couple years.

example: http://forum.redump.org/topic/41618/cdi … d-windows/

Did you know those two are the same disc?

http://redump.org/disc/67064/
http://redump.org/disc/85477/

Every time I dump that disc it will generate one of the two hashes every time randomly. The first Asterix XXL also with Tages does the same but I didn't added that.



EDIT: Today I have redumped this disc 5 times with two different drives models. This time I always get this result: http://redump.org/disc/67064/

So mine dump is wrong I assume?

The first Asterix XXL game still result in different hashes though. Here are the dumps from two drives (sr1 & sr2 are essentially the drive letters, all are MD5):

sr2=791d6da9c485e8bd3c8cbd36223f4761
sr2=f11fb84c4fb0e0cd4e0e797448edcd10
sr2=f11fb84c4fb0e0cd4e0e797448edcd10
sr1=e5eccaf34acf439c14c255c424636d80
sr2=791d6da9c485e8bd3c8cbd36223f4761
sr2=e5eccaf34acf439c14c255c424636d80
sr1=791d6da9c485e8bd3c8cbd36223f4761
sr1=e5eccaf34acf439c14c255c424636d80

3,175 Reply by Jackal (edited by Jackal 2022-01-10 19:41:21)

  • Jackal
  • Moderator (Retired)
  • Offline
  • Registered: 2006-12-23
  • Posts: 4,132

https://mega.nz/folder/0NQh3QgL#Y2vjOQAxojTAPB4xJtjvIw

No PVD is detected on this disc, but sector 16 has a normal PVD, so I wonder what the problem is?

Post's attachments

pvd.png 22.56 kb, 14 downloads since 2022-01-10 

You don't have the permssions to download the attachments of this post.