1 (edited by benclaff 2018-03-10 18:17:54)

Topic: [CDI] dump error shared by several CDI discs

Hi,

I dumped dozens of CDIs disc over the last weeks, and I managed to use DiscImageCreator successfully with most of them.
Any game already in the database showed matching checksums and will upload them soon for verification.
However, I do not manage to dump 4 particular discs and there all present the same issue

I used a plextor PX-708A.
I used DiscImageCreator.exe, version "x86, AnsiBuild, Mar  4 2018 15:29:36".

The games are:
-The Lost ride, 810 9990
-Lost Eden (french), 812 0154
-Scotland Yard (french), 812 0070
-Zenith, 814 0112

Dumping them with clonCD is ok, which means the disc are in a good state.

Dumping produces similar error ouputs:
-DiscImageCrerator standard output

LBA[166792, 0x28b88]: [F:ReadDirectoryRecord][L:1014]
        Opcode: 0xa8
        ScsiStatus: 0x02 = CHECK_CONDITION
        SenseData Key-Asc-Ascq: 05-21-00 = ILLEGAL_REQUEST - LOGICAL BLOCK ADDRESS OUT OF RANGE
lpCmd: a8, 00, 00, 02, 8b, 88, 00, 00, 00, 01, 00, 00
dwBufSize: 2048
End time: 2018-03-10(Sat) 17:49:41

-mainError.txt

Directory Record is invalid

Now, this becomes interesting because 2 out these 4 disc (Zenith, The lost ride) were dumped previously by the member Jackal.
I contacted him and he he redirected me to 2 older versions of DiscImageCreator.
- version A:  x86, AnsiBuild, Oct 16 2014 14:37:59
- version B:  x86, AnsiBuild, Jul 14 2015 21:50:46

With the older version B (2015), I managed to successfully dump "Zenith" but none of the 3 others.
With older version A, none of the 4 discs can be dumped, like the most recent version

These older version also lead to the exact same errors, which fits the error of the most recent version (directory error):
(DiscImageCreator standard output)

Start: 2018-03-10(Sat) 18:08:52
Checking reading lead-out
Read command: 0xd8, Subcode reading mode: Pack
Creating bin from 15752 to 15753 (LBA)  15753
Reading lead-out: OK
[F:ReadCDAll][L:792] GetLastError: 2, Le fichier spÚcifiÚ est introuvable.

End: 2018-03-10(Sat) 18:08:57

Is there anyone that encountered this error before and has an idea how to overcome it ?

Thank you !

Re: [CDI] dump error shared by several CDI discs

Hi.

sarami wrote:

1. Before you report a bug, could you test the latest test version. Nevertheless a bug exists, could you upload all created file except bin, img and scm.

Re: [CDI] dump error shared by several CDI discs

Dear Sarami,

You will find below a link to the outputs I got for these 4 discs, using the last version of Discimagecreator (04032018) and the same drive as above (Plextor PX-708A).
No CD images are created, as it crashes before starting to write them.

https://www.dropbox.com/s/az1qbpbcrr878 … r.zip?dl=0

Cheers,

benclaff

Re: [CDI] dump error shared by several CDI discs

Thanks.

I noticed that file attribution of CD-I was irregular.

generic disc (e.g. Sega Saturn)

========== LBA[000018, 0x00012]: Path Table Record ==========
         Length of Directory Identifier: 1
    Length of Extended Attribute Record: 0
                     Position of Extent: 20
              Number of Upper Directory: 1
                   Directory Identifier: 
         Length of Directory Identifier: 5
    Length of Extended Attribute Record: 0
                     Position of Extent: 25
              Number of Upper Directory: 1
                   Directory Identifier: EXTRA

         Length of Directory Identifier: 3
    Length of Extended Attribute Record: 0
                     Position of Extent: 26
              Number of Upper Directory: 2
                   Directory Identifier: 16M

         Length of Directory Identifier: 3
    Length of Extended Attribute Record: 0
                     Position of Extent: 27
              Number of Upper Directory: 2
                   Directory Identifier: 256

Directory Num: 4

EXTRA, 16M, 256 is directory.

========== LBA[000020, 0x00014]: Directory Record ==========
                     :
              Length of Directory Record: 38
        Extended Attribute Record Length: 0
                      Location of Extent: 25
                             Data Length: 2048
                 Recording Date and Time: 1996-10-29 01:00:00 +09:00
                              File Flags: 2 (Visible, Directory, Disassociated, File has't record format, Owner/Group ID has't, Final Directory Record)
                          File Unit Size: 0
                     Interleave Gap Size: 0
                  Volume Sequence Number: 1
               Length of File Identifier: 5
                         File Identifier: EXTRA
                    :
                    :
========== LBA[000025, 0x00019]: Directory Record ==========
                    :
              Length of Directory Record: 36
        Extended Attribute Record Length: 0
                      Location of Extent: 26
                             Data Length: 2048
                 Recording Date and Time: 1996-10-29 01:00:00 +09:00
                              File Flags: 2 (Visible, Directory, Disassociated, File has't record format, Owner/Group ID has't, Final Directory Record)
                          File Unit Size: 0
                     Interleave Gap Size: 0
                  Volume Sequence Number: 1
               Length of File Identifier: 3
                         File Identifier: 16M

              Length of Directory Record: 36
        Extended Attribute Record Length: 0
                      Location of Extent: 27
                             Data Length: 2048
                 Recording Date and Time: 1996-10-29 01:00:00 +09:00
                              File Flags: 2 (Visible, Directory, Disassociated, File has't record format, Owner/Group ID has't, Final Directory Record)
                          File Unit Size: 0
                     Interleave Gap Size: 0
                  Volume Sequence Number: 1
               Length of File Identifier: 3
                         File Identifier: 256
                    :

File Flags of 3 directories is '2' (2 is directory).

But, CD-I disc is all '0'.

========== LBA[002268, 0x008dc]: Path Table Record ==========
         Length of Directory Identifier: 1
    Length of Extended Attribute Record: 0
                     Position of Extent: 2269
              Number of Upper Directory: 1
                   Directory Identifier: 

         Length of Directory Identifier: 4
    Length of Extended Attribute Record: 0
                     Position of Extent: 15505
              Number of Upper Directory: 1
                   Directory Identifier: CMDS

         Length of Directory Identifier: 3
    Length of Extended Attribute Record: 0
                     Position of Extent: 2273
              Number of Upper Directory: 1
                   Directory Identifier: LEV

         Length of Directory Identifier: 5
    Length of Extended Attribute Record: 0
                     Position of Extent: 8793
              Number of Upper Directory: 1
                   Directory Identifier: MUSIC

         Length of Directory Identifier: 3
    Length of Extended Attribute Record: 0
                     Position of Extent: 13206
              Number of Upper Directory: 1
                   Directory Identifier: RTF

         Length of Directory Identifier: 3
    Length of Extended Attribute Record: 0
                     Position of Extent: 8766
              Number of Upper Directory: 1
                   Directory Identifier: VIZ

Directory Num: 6
              Length of Directory Record: 48
        Extended Attribute Record Length: 0
                      Location of Extent: 15505
                             Data Length: 142
                 Recording Date and Time: 1997-10-30 15:40:24 +00:00
                              File Flags: 0 (Visible, File, Disassociated, File has't record format, Owner/Group ID has't, Final Directory Record)
                          File Unit Size: 0
                     Interleave Gap Size: 0
                  Volume Sequence Number: 0
               Length of File Identifier: 4
                         File Identifier: CMDS
                    :
              Length of Directory Record: 46
        Extended Attribute Record Length: 0
                      Location of Extent: 2273
                             Data Length: 474
                 Recording Date and Time: 1997-10-30 15:37:51 +00:00
                              File Flags: 0 (Visible, File, Disassociated, File has't record format, Owner/Group ID has't, Final Directory Record)
                          File Unit Size: 0
                     Interleave Gap Size: 0
                  Volume Sequence Number: 0
               Length of File Identifier: 3
                         File Identifier: LEV
                    :
                    :

So, dic can't read these sub directory record. Zenith, The lost ride, Scotland yard and Lost Eden have sub directory. Please wait until I get these discs.

Re: [CDI] dump error shared by several CDI discs

fixed: CD-I ignores File Flags
Please try the latest test version.

Re: [CDI] dump error shared by several CDI discs

sarami wrote:

Please try the latest test version.

Dear Sarami,
I was already using the last version (20180304) and this is the one that gave me these errors
On github, this is still the last available release (whatever the branch, test or master, last modification was 20 days ago.

Is there another repository where I could find a more recent version ?

Thanks,

Re: [CDI] dump error shared by several CDI discs

Forget my previous post, I realize now that the link is in the DiscImageCreator forum page.

Re: [CDI] dump error shared by several CDI discs

Hi,

I confirm that the 4 games can now be dumped correctly.
Thank you for your help !

9 (edited by fuzzball 2018-04-01 07:43:12)

Re: [CDI] dump error shared by several CDI discs

FYI,
A similar error occurred on the PlayStation 2 DVD.

Mar  4 2018 15:29:36 NG (logs)
Mar 31 2018 21:49:29 OK