I have both Plextor PX760 and Asus BW-16D1HT and I've been dumping discs with both of them since quite some time. After dumping few hundreds discs (with both of them for comparision) I can say that Asus is not 100% reliable with positive combined offset discs where data is taken from cache.
From time to time last few samples are bad (for example if combined offset is X samples I get X last samples bad). I haven't debugged if it's firmware issue or DIC bug). Most of the time reripping the disc 2nd time produces correct dump.
http://forum.redump.org/post/89943/#p89943 -> I have this issue. Most probably bad dump. Rerip.
> The audio tracks all seem to the data starting 4 bytes later than Nexy's Plextor dump
Haven't observed it. Probably different master disc.
Example off hand (Asus):
LBA[378268, 0x5c59c], mode 1
LBA[378269, 0x5c59d], mode 1
LBA[378270, 0x5c59e], mode 1
LBA[378271, 0x5c59f], mode 1 User data vs. ecc/edc doesn't match
[ERROR] Number of sector(s) where user data doesn't match the expected ECC/EDC: 1
Sector: 378271,
If you see this in console:
========== Reading 378251 - 378271 INTO CACHE ==========
01 Cache LBA 378251, SubQ Trk 01, AMSF 84:05:27
02 Cache LBA 378252, SubQ Trk 01, AMSF 84:05:28
03 Cache LBA 378253, SubQ Trk 01, AMSF 84:05:29
04 Cache LBA 378254, SubQ Trk 01, AMSF 84:05:30
05 Cache LBA 378255, SubQ Trk 01, AMSF 84:05:31
06 Cache LBA 378256, SubQ Trk 01, AMSF 84:05:32
07 Cache LBA 378257, SubQ Trk 01, AMSF 84:05:33
08 Cache LBA 378258, SubQ Trk 01, AMSF 84:05:34
09 Cache LBA 378259, SubQ Trk 01, AMSF 84:05:35
10 Cache LBA 378260, SubQ Trk 01, AMSF 84:05:36
11 Cache LBA 378261, SubQ Trk 01, AMSF 84:05:37
12 Cache LBA 378262, SubQ Trk 01, AMSF 84:05:38
13 Cache LBA 378263, SubQ Trk 01, AMSF 84:05:39
14 Cache LBA 378264, SubQ Trk 01, AMSF 84:05:40
15 Cache LBA 378265, SubQ Trk 01, AMSF 84:05:41
16 Cache LBA 378266, SubQ Trk 01, AMSF 84:05:42
17 Cache LBA 378267, SubQ Trk 01, AMSF 84:05:43
18 Cache LBA 378268, SubQ Trk 01, AMSF 84:05:44
19 Cache LBA 378269, SubQ Trk 01, AMSF 84:05:45
20 Cache LBA 378270, SubQ Trk 01, AMSF 84:05:46
21 Cache LBA 378271, SubQ Trk aa, AMSF 84:05:47
22 Cache LBA 378272, SubQ Trk aa, AMSF 84:05:48 [Lead-out]
23 Cache LBA 378273, SubQ Trk aa, AMSF 84:05:49 [Lead-out]
24 Cache LBA 378274, SubQ Trk aa, AMSF 84:05:50 [Lead-out]
25 Cache LBA 378275, SubQ Trk aa, AMSF 84:05:51 [Lead-out]
26 Cache LBA 378276, SubQ Trk aa, AMSF 84:05:52 [Lead-out]
27 Cache LBA 378277, SubQ Trk aa, AMSF 84:05:53 [Lead-out]
28 Cache LBA 378278, SubQ Trk aa, AMSF 84:05:54 [Lead-out]
29 Cache LBA 378279, SubQ Trk aa, AMSF 84:05:55 [Lead-out]
30 Cache LBA 378280, SubQ Trk aa, AMSF 84:05:56 [Lead-out]
31 Cache LBA 378281, SubQ Trk aa, AMSF 84:05:57 [Lead-out]
32 Cache LBA 378282, SubQ Trk aa, AMSF 84:05:58 [Lead-out]
33 Cache LBA 378283, SubQ Trk aa, AMSF 84:05:59 [Lead-out]
34 Cache LBA 378284, SubQ Trk aa, AMSF 84:05:60 [Lead-out]
35 Cache LBA 378285, SubQ Trk aa, AMSF 84:05:61 [Lead-out]
36 Cache LBA 378286, SubQ Trk aa, AMSF 84:05:62 [Lead-out]
37 Cache LBA 378287, SubQ Trk aa, AMSF 84:05:63 [Lead-out]
38 Cache LBA 378288, SubQ Trk aa, AMSF 84:05:64 [Lead-out]
Better watch out for bad dumpies...
IMHO audio tracks made with Asus and positive offset discs should be temp banned unless fully resolved 
Post's attachmentsPrzechwytywanie.PNG 29.71 kb, 13 downloads since 2021-05-18
You don't have the permssions to download the attachments of this post.
