1 (edited by camb702 2012-07-11 14:47:46)

Below are some results I obtained using jamjam's CDGroup utility. Although intended for internal use, I thought they might prove useful for reference purposes.

Conditions were as follows:

  • Dataset: PSX (all regions)

  • Discs were regionally grouped where available

  • Demos were appropriately grouped with full releases

  • Multiple point releases were grouped

  • Multi-disc titles were appropriately grouped

  • Audio tracks were compressed post-split (ape -c5000)

  • t7z was replaced with 7z 7.25a, 64 bit (-mx9 -m0=LZMA:d1024m:fb273 -mmt2)

  • Time stamps and file attributes were scrubbed from all of the archives for consistency and cross-compatibility.

  • All discs conformed to Redump standard

Merged sets adhere to Redump.org naming convention with the following alterations:

  • Merged set containing 2 or more regions have no regional suffix assigned (those containing only 1 region retain their regional suffix as before)

  • Multi-disc title within a merged set has the disc label removed

  • Multi-point release within a merged set has the version label removed

  • Merged name: USA>Europe>Japan

Of the chosen sample data, 881 discs were grouped down to 197. Each title in the dataset below is suffixed by 3 numbers: combined torrent7z size (MB), cdgroup size (MB) and the ratio between the two (in red).


Summary

Raw size (GB):
489.1

torrent7z size (GB):
257.4

CDGroup size (GB):
80.0


Relative compression:

http://i.imgur.com/LfDLZ.gif

X-Axis: Merged set # / Y-Axis: Compression ratio relative to t7z


Dataset

3D Lemmings    1214.3    299.5    0.2
3x3 Eyes - Kyuusei Kousyu (Japan)    577.1    353.0    0.6
3x3 Eyes - Tenrinou Genmu (Japan)    654.5    368.3    0.6
A Ressha de Ikou 4 - Evolution Global (Japan)    143.3    83.1    0.6
Ace Combat 2    1179.8    322.4    0.3
Ace Combat 3 - Electrosphere    1987.1    589.8    0.3
Aconcagua (Japan)    365.3    267.3    0.7
Air Combat    1615.8    593.4    0.4
Akagawa Jiro - Yasoukyoku (Japan)    308.8    132.3    0.4
Alien Trilogy    1446.1    244.5    0.2
Alnam no Tsubasa - Shoujin no Sora no Kanata e (Japan)    663.5    451.4    0.7
Alundra 2 - A New Legend Begins    1356.4    763.2    0.6
Alundra    2037.7    252.8    0.1
Animetic Story Game 1 - Card Captor Sakura (Japan)    546.6    387.0    0.7
Ape Escape    676.8    333.3    0.5
Arc the Lad Collection - Arc the Lad II    731.3    316.0    0.4
Arc the Lad Collection - Arc the Lad III    1003.1    425.0    0.4
Arc the Lad Collection - Arc the Lad    416.0    297.4    0.7
Area 51    1094.3    283.1    0.3
Armored Core - Master of Arena    1631.8    260.1    0.2
Armored Core - Project Phantasma    579.0    160.4    0.3
Armored Core    709.8    195.3    0.3
B Senjou no Alice - Alice on Borderlines (Japan)    1199.6    1012.9    0.8
Back Guiner - Yomigaeru Yuusha Tachi - Hishou Hen 'Uragiri no Senjou' (Japan)    591.2    403.0    0.7
Back Guiner - Yomigaeru Yuusha Tachi - Kakusei Hen 'Guiner Tensei' (Japan)    587.3    390.5    0.7
Bounty Sword - Double Edge (Japan)    639.5    297.7    0.5
Brave Fencer Musashi    518.2    232.3    0.4
Breath of Fire III    234.5    53.6    0.2
Breath of Fire IV    466.8    116.7    0.2
Brigandine - Grand Edition (Japan)    821.2    550.6    0.7
Bushido Blade 2    532.4    332.6    0.6
Bushido Blade    734.2    333.8    0.5
Castlevania - Symphony of the Night    1714.5    384.2    0.2
Chibi Chara Game Ginga Eiyuu Densetsu (Reinhart Version) (Japan)    311.8    239.4    0.8
Chocobo's Dungeon 2    474.1    243.7    0.5
Chou Jikuu Yousai Macross - Ai Oboete Imasu ka (Japan)    346.4    302.5    0.9
Chrono Cross    1334.0    412.2    0.3
Crash Bandicoot - Warped    433.3    240.0    0.6
Crash Bandicoot 2 - Cortex Strikes Back    393.6    127.8    0.3
Crash Bandicoot    1714.6    372.7    0.2
Crash Bash    403.0    277.0    0.7
Cross Tantei Monogatari (Japan)    522.2    394.4    0.8
CTR - Crash Team Racing    1120.5    466.0    0.4
Dancing Blade Katte ni Momotenshi II - Tears of Eden (Japan)    840.1    658.2    0.8
Dancing Blade Katte ni Momotenshi! (Japan)    703.0    487.0    0.7
Darkstalkers 3    1263.0    412.6    0.3
Dead or Alive    1263.6    346.5    0.3
Devil Summoner - Soul Hackers (Japan)    489.5    271.5    0.6
Diablo    799.4    290.2    0.4
Die Hard Trilogy 2 - Viva Las Vegas    717.0    316.0    0.4
Die Hard Trilogy    1223.0    318.6    0.3
Dino Crisis 2    1419.4    589.6    0.4
Dino Crisis    1059.1    263.1    0.2
Dokapon! Ikari no Tekken (Japan)    134.1    34.8    0.3
Doki Doki Pretty League - Nekketsu Otome Seishunki (Japan)    1024.0    610.7    0.6
Dragon Ball GT - Final Bout    431.6    100.7    0.2
Dragon Ball Z - Ultimate Battle 22    1217.1    155.5    0.1
Dragon Valor    701.8    112.8    0.2
Dragon Warrior VII    1417.5    421.3    0.3
Driver - You Are the Wheelman    1814.5    658.5    0.4
Eberouge (Japan)    787.0    520.9    0.7
Echo Night    319.8    157.3    0.5
Ehrgeiz - God Bless the Ring    1332.6    422.1    0.3
Einhander    631.2    254.9    0.4
Eithea (Japan)    455.4    325.0    0.7
Enigma (Japan)    817.3    658.7    0.8
Evil Zone    1350.4    726.3    0.5
Final Fantasy Anthology    906.5    277.7    0.3
Final Fantasy Chronicles - Chrono Trigger    764.1    245.3    0.3
Final Fantasy Chronicles - Final Fantasy IV    823.4    178.2    0.2
Final Fantasy IX    11586.6    1204.6    0.1
Final Fantasy Origins    412.6    82.0    0.2
Final Fantasy Tactics    545.3    219.2    0.4
Final Fantasy VII International (Japan) (Disc 4) (Perfect Guide)    398.8    340.0    0.9
Final Fantasy VII    10626.1    1174.3    0.1
Final Fantasy VIII    12411.1    1400.9    0.1
From TV Animation One Piece - Tobidase Kaizokudan! (Japan)    744.9    310.3    0.4
Front Mission 2 (Japan)    249.6    101.0    0.4
Front Mission 3    917.5    267.2    0.3
G-Police    3730.7    1148.5    0.3
G. Darius    1112.5    348.7    0.3
Galaxian 3    754.9    333.0    0.4
Ganbare Goemon - Uchuu Kaizoku Akogingu (Japan)    728.7    353.3    0.5
Global Force - Shin Sentou Kokka (Japan)    271.7    137.5    0.5
Gradius Gaiden (Japan)    587.7    282.4    0.5
Gran Turismo 2    4035.7    1481.0    0.4
Gran Turismo    2094.0    565.2    0.3
Grandia    3182.6    872.4    0.3
Guardian Recall - Shugojuu Shoukan (Japan)    830.1    669.5    0.8
Gundam 0079 - The War for Earth (Japan)    410.8    286.4    0.7
Gungage    327.3    135.1    0.4
Harukaze Sentai V-Force (Japan)    770.3    465.9    0.6
Hellnight    716.1    574.4    0.8
Hot Shots Golf 2    506.4    167.7    0.3
Hot Shots Golf    443.1    122.9    0.3
Jikuu Tantei DD - Maboroshi no Lorelei (Japan)    520.9    359.0    0.7
Jikuu Tantei DD 2 - Hangyaku no Apusararu (Japan)    486.6    387.9    0.8
JoJo's Bizarre Adventure    1145.4    381.4    0.3
Juggernaut    2195.9    974.0    0.4
Jumping Flash! 2    675.3    215.4    0.3
Jumping Flash!    609.7    205.0    0.3
Kidou Senshi Gundam - Gyakushuu no Char (Japan)    547.8    223.1    0.4
Kidou Senshi Z-Gundam (Japan)    1637.0    554.6    0.3
Kindaichi Shounen no Jikenbo 2 - Jigoku Yuuen Satsujin Jiken (Japan)    846.9    680.0    0.8
King's Field II    723.6    272.6    0.4
King's Field    333.2    174.3    0.5
Klonoa - Beach Volleyball    190.0    92.9    0.5
Koudelka    4016.4    1363.7    0.3
Lunar - Silver Star Story Complete    1247.3    782.0    0.6
Maria - Kimitachi ga Umareta Wake (Japan)    801.9    633.5    0.8
Maria 2 - Jutai Kokuchi no Nazo (Japan)    854.8    593.1    0.7
Megaman - Battle & Chase    684.7    288.1    0.4
Megami Ibunroku Persona - Be Your True Mind (Japan)    549.7    210.6    0.4
Meltylancer - Re-inforce (Japan)    811.3    615.5    0.8
Metal Gear Solid - VR Missions    909.9    483.6    0.5
Metal Gear Solid    7287.3    3421.1    0.5
Myst    1290.8    501.2    0.4
Namco Museum Encore (Japan)    588.6    276.8    0.5
NBA in the Zone '98    529.0    208.6    0.4
NBA in the Zone '99    654.5    294.2    0.4
NBA in the Zone 2    458.6    122.3    0.3
NBA in the Zone 2000    363.6    121.8    0.3
NBA in the Zone    640.4    152.8    0.2
Nessa no Hoshi (Japan)    925.0    629.1    0.7
Nightmare Project - Yakata (Japan)    491.1    326.8    0.7
NOeL - La Neige (Japan)    1820.1    480.4    0.3
NOeL - Not Digital (Japan)    1241.2    579.8    0.5
NOeL 3 - Mission on the Line (Japan)    962.8    586.4    0.6
Novastorm    2280.3    698.4    0.3
Option - Tuning Car Battle (Japan)    784.7    281.8    0.4
PaRappa the Rapper    955.5    499.1    0.5
Parasite Eve II    4049.0    624.0    0.2
Parasite Eve    1064.8    393.3    0.4
R4 - Ridge Racer Type 4    989.7    415.5    0.4
Rage Racer    2431.7    466.5    0.2
Resident Evil - Survivor    567.3    150.8    0.3
Resident Evil 2    6884.4    743.7    0.1
Resident Evil 3 - Nemesis    2423.4    194.8    0.1
Resident Evil    3998.9    491.8    0.1
Ridge Racer Revolution    2257.7    596.1    0.3
Ridge Racer    1050.4    284.9    0.3
Rival Schools - United by Fate    1444.2    506.9    0.4
SaGa Frontier 2    785.1    151.5    0.2
SaGa Frontier    313.3    100.3    0.3
Silent Hill    1048.3    244.3    0.2
Sister Princess (Japan)    1352.0    476.8    0.4
Sister Princess 2 (Japan)    2190.4    733.9    0.3
Skydiving Extreme    510.6    237.4    0.5
Sol Divide    173.5    86.1    0.5
Soul Blade    1285.7    335.5    0.3
Star Ixiom    443.4    269.0    0.6
Star Ocean - The Second Story    2241.7    366.4    0.2
Starblade Alpha    1199.7    325.4    0.3
Street Fighter - The Movie    893.9    330.6    0.4
Street Fighter Alpha - Warriors' Dreams    1443.2    403.6    0.3
Street Fighter Alpha 2    868.9    272.0    0.3
Street Fighter Alpha 3    838.3    266.4    0.3
Street Fighter Collection 2    445.9    214.3    0.5
Street Fighter Collection    1567.5    613.0    0.4
Street Fighter EX Plus Alpha    746.0    241.6    0.3
Street Fighter EX2 Plus    561.8    184.8    0.3
Street Fighter II Movie (Japan)    844.9    692.9    0.8
Strikers 1945 II    523.9    224.4    0.4
Suikoden II    1311.6    258.4    0.2
Suikoden    1693.0    278.2    0.2
Tales of Destiny II    1719.7    822.8    0.5
Tales of Fandom Vol. 1 (Japan)    624.6    296.8    0.5
Tantei Jinguji Saburo - Early Collection (Japan)    505.3    238.1    0.5
Tekken 2    1894.5    430.2    0.2
Tekken 3    1851.8    480.0    0.3
Tekken    2266.0    395.9    0.2
Tenchu - Stealth Assassins    1682.0    631.3    0.4
Tenchu 2 - Birth of the Stealth Assassins    1914.2    872.9    0.5
Tennis no Oujisama - Sweat & Tears (Japan)    652.8    298.9    0.5
Theme Park    397.3    120.6    0.3
Thousand Arms    1735.0    695.8    0.4
Threads of Fate    93.2    25.6    0.3
Time Crisis - Project Titan    1117.9    322.6    0.3
Time Crisis    1548.0    371.7    0.2
Tobal 2 (Japan)    769.9    339.2    0.4
Tobal No.1    1266.6    296.2    0.2
Tokimeki Memorial - Forever with You (Japan)    1414.5    441.7    0.3
Tomb Raider - The Last Revelation    2826.6    629.9    0.2
Tomb Raider Chronicles    2473.8    854.0    0.3
Tomb Raider II    3630.7    518.8    0.1
Tomb Raider III - Adventures of Lara Croft    4309.6    533.0    0.1
Tomb Raider    4022.4    479.8    0.1
Um Jammer Lammy    1889.7    719.5    0.4
Vagrant Story    337.7    48.8    0.1
Valkyrie Profile    1954.4    438.9    0.2
Vandal Hearts II    374.7    80.0    0.2
Vandal Hearts    706.6    453.0    0.6
Wild Arms 2    1256.5    297.9    0.2
Wild Arms    1690.9    257.5    0.2
WipEout XL    2262.6    420.6    0.2
WipEout    2078.1    394.7    0.2
Xenogears    1305.1    524.4    0.4