Hi everyone,
I found a PX-712UF for cheap this week, and hoped that it would finally allow me to start contributing. The drive worked fine when I initially tested it after getting it, but after doing the v1.09 firmware update requested by DIC, it now seems to no longer read CDs, only DVDs.
Here's the full story:
When I first set up the drive (USB connection, Windows 10 machine) I tested it with a handful of CD-ROMs and DVD-ROMs I had lying around. The drive read all of them flawlessly. I then tried to do my first dump with DIC, but the tool complained that it wouldn't dump from the drive since it had the v1.02 firmware installed, and I should update it to the latest version 1.09.
I downloaded the firmware updater from the link on the Wiki, and the update seemed to go smoothly. However, when I inserted the CD I tried dumping again, the drive wouldn't recognise it anymore. It audibly tried detecting the disc four times, before going into the "two orange LED flashes" error mode. I tried the other CDs that worked fine before the firmware upgrade, and none of them were recognised anymore either. I then tried the DVDs again – and they all still read flawlessly. The drive immediately detects them, seems to read them at full speed, and I can even dump them with DIC.
Since the drive sucessfully read CDs on every try before the firmware upgrade, and not a single time anymore after it, I figured it had to do with the firmware. I downgraded it back to v1.02 to try (which would defeat the purpose of wanting to use the drive for dumping, but whatever). But still: I can't get it to recognise a single CD-ROM anymore. DVDs always work fine.
What could be the problem here? Of course I've read the notes about the 712's reputation of having its lasers die young, but I'm a bit skeptical about this being the problem given how the success rate went from 100% to 0% the second I upgraded the firmware, and the fact that it doesn't seem to have any problems with DVDs whatsoever (or does the 712 have separate lasers?). Could I have semi-bricked the drive when flashing the firmware? Could it just need a lens cleaning? Or are these symptoms actually consistent with the laser dying?
The guy who sold the drive to me asked me about what system I plan to connect it to – he said that the drive was very unreliable for him whenever he tried using it on a Windows 8 or 10 machine, but that he managed to back up all of his old discs flawlessly once he connected it to an old XP computer. My intuition tells me that this couldn't possibly be it, and that the failure happens before anything the Windows driver could influence gets involved. But maybe I'm wrong?
I'd appreciate any helpful experiences or knowledge you might have! Thanks